Sate your snack fix with the city’s flakiest, tastiest Caribbean foods—as picked by locals in the know.
Patties are the perfect snack—portable, affordable, and if your patty has a flaky crust and a perfectly seasoned filling, it just might be the GOAT. With input from local food lovers who’ve spent a lifetime eating patties, I’ve compiled a list of the city’s best.
Spoiler alert: almost no one could choose just one.
Kingston 12 Patty Shop: The Challenger (Author’s Pick)
Location: 1808 Eglinton Ave West
Local Food-Loving Fan: Ryan Hinkson (@EatFamous), Food Culturalist
Opening just blocks from the legendary Randy’s Patties might seem risky, but Kingston 12 has thrived despite the pressure.
Their golden, flaky patties filled with expertly seasoned meat have earned a loyal following. The specialty patties—like beef and cheese or ackee and saltfish—stand strong alongside the classic spicy beef, never feeling gimmicky or forced.
Fahmee Bakery: Your Travel Buddy
Location: 222 Lansdowne Avenue Unit B
Local Food-Loving Fan: Melissa Ayisi (@BigBellyMel), Content Creator
Mel, who reps Scarborough proudly, reminisces, “Fahmee was responsible for many fond memories of grabbing a delicious patty at Warden Station.” They’re no longer at their original Scarborough spot due to a devastating fire, but she still remembers every bite.
She adds with a laugh, “People debated for years about which TTC station—Warden, Islington, or Bathurst—had the best patties. Ironically, Fahmee supplied them all, meaning folks were arguing over the same patty!”
Notably, Fahmee now serves 100% halal meat during Ramadan and offers a delicious vegan patty, catering to diverse dietary needs.
Patty Time: Worth the Wait
Location: 2919 Lawrence Avenue East
Local Food-Loving Fan: Chef Dwight Smith (@chefdwightsmith)
We’ve all heard “Patience is a virtue,” and you’ll need plenty at Patty Time, a Scarborough favourite that regularly sees long lines.
But it’s worth it: these patties are baked fresh onsite. Chef Dwight, whose viral patty recipes boast millions of social media views, swears by Patty Time. He praises their patties, saying, “The crust has the right amount of flake, and the filling is well-seasoned, hot, and consistently juicy. Beef is my go-to, but their chicken patties are equally delicious.”
Pro tip: Bring cash, as this spot accepts no cards.
Patties Express: The Food Court Saviour
Location: Multiple Locations (including Eaton Centre)
Local Food-Loving Fan: Azalea Hart (@azaleahart), CHUM 1045 Radio Host & Personality
Food courts can be overwhelming—too many choices, crowded seating, or questionable cleanliness. Patties Express cuts through the chaos with a straightforward, tasty menu featuring beef patties in various spice levels, chicken, and vegan options.
Azalea Hart particularly enjoys their Eaton Centre location, saying, “I don’t have a single favourite patty spot, but Patties Express always satisfies.”
Jrew Creations: The New Kids on the Block
Location: 44 Tecumseth Street
Local Food-Loving Fan: Benji Agbeke and Nicole Brumley (@benji.agbeke, @benandnics), Videographers & Food Creators
Benji and Nicole enthusiastically describe Jrew Creations’ offerings: "They serve the most buttery patties we’ve tasted in the city, with fillings like curry chicken, oxtail, and spicy beef. Lines form daily for these delicious treats.”
Their brightly lit stall also doubles as a spot for trendy crocheted fashion pieces, making it a memorable visit. Check their Instagram for daily offerings.
Pattie World Bakery: Mash-up Masterpieces
Location: 86 Guided Court
Local Food-Loving Fan: Paul McGhie and Tim Grant (@marvedtv), Food Content Creators
Paul and Tim from Marved TV insist Pattie World Bakery is unbeatable when it comes to unique offerings. “You go for the ackee and saltfish patty,” they affirm. “We've debated this endlessly.”
Though their classic beef patty and excellent customer service are praised, their standout offerings fuse Jamaican classics like oxtail, callaloo, and ackee and saltfish with their signature flaky crust—truly a delicious mash-up worth the drive.
Michidean Limited: Best Bang for Your Buck
Location: 7725 Birchmount Road, Unit 28
Local Food-Loving Fan: Trevor Lui (@trevorlui), Author and CEO of Highbell Hospitality Group
Note: This one is in Markham, a short drive outside the Greater Toronto Area (GTA).
Once, while grabbing oxtail at a Jamaican restaurant, I spontaneously added a beef patty to my order. To my surprise, it became the standout bite. Curious about its origins, I discovered Michidean was the supplier.
At just $20 for a box of 12 ($1.66 each), Michidean’s patties deliver exceptional value.
Trevor Lui co-signs and echoes my love for them, noting, “Michidean patties offer the perfect balance. The filling is subtly seasoned, and the pastry is buttery and flaky enough that you’ll want to savour every crumb. Their obscure location and unpredictable hours only add to the intrigue!”
